I originally wrote this in August 2009. It still pertains, though I’d probably write it a bit differently today. Slightly edited:
There is no doubt that this country is not ready for a Black President.
Nor would this country ever be ready for any non-white or non-male president until we actually went ahead and elected one–ready or not–and then made the necessary adjustments. And that could have been what would have happened with the historic election of Barack Obama.
Except it didn’t.
Join me, if you will, in a moment of utter, deep cynicism. That would mean you thinking, for just a moment, exactly like I think every second of the day. This will be painful for you, unless you are already where I am. In my world, I see almost every nationally elected Republican, almost every one of the teabaggers at the town hall meetings, and almost every one of the strutting libertarians with their strap-ons (because they don’t have real ones) as a racist. I also see half the liberals that I know as racists. I see almost every white person who lives in the suburbs and who has a job and an income with benefits as a racist. I probably think you are a racist. You may think I’m over doing it, you may think I’m being unfair, you may think I’ve oversimplified, and you may think I’ve got it wrong.
I have oversimplified, but I’m not overdoing it, I’m not being unfair, and I don’t have it wrong. It is you that has it wrong and that is the problem. Standing by and letting what we are seeing happening on the national stage and doing nothing about it is plain and pure complicity.
I’m thinking about the response to health care reform. The most active of them all, the teabaggers and the Republicans in office, each and every one, are reacting not to anything about health care, but rather to the fact that our president is a black man, and they are reacting to little else. Proposals that the Republicans have made themselves over the last decade are being touted as attempts to kill grandma or take away our freedoms or introduce socialism. There is nothing rational in what the teabaggers and Republicans are saying. Not. One. Thing.
Does any of this mean that we have prematurely elected our first black president? No, of course not. That is all to be expected. That would all be part of the transformation our country will go through to make the election of non-white-male presidents (in some combination) plausible rather than jaw-dropping remarkable.
The problem is not that the crazy right wing is upset and screaming at us from the back of the room telling us to shut up. The problem is that the rest of the country, or at least a significant number of individuals, especially in elected office and in the media, are not calling this what it is. Yes, there have been hints, here and there, of racist undertones and overtones, but the spade is not being called a spade. As it were.
And the reason is disgusting. The reason that the mainstream press and numerous elected officials are not identifying the town hall teabaggers and the anti-health care Republicans as racists is because the ground has been prepared to make sure that when someone does call someone else out on racism in the mainstream public square, that act…the act of identifying racism…is considered just as bad as the racism itself. It is called “playing the race card.” The whole “Oh, now you’re going to play the race card, aren’t you!” gambit was developed, prepared, and inculcated into society over the last 15 years (really, 14 years…since the OJ Simpson trial), so now racism has a place at the table. Where it does not belong.
Over the last 24 hours (as I write this on Monday) the public option part of health care reform has been taken off the table. I can hope, tell myself, guess, fantasize, that this is just a strategy, and that the public option will be back. I can figure that this is just to give some time for the famous Obama grassroots organizing to get up to speed, and that the public option will be in the health care bill and will be voted into place. But I doubt it. I strongly suspect that the golden opportunity, which comes around very 12 to 20 years, has been lost once more.
I will die before there is a good health care system. My daughter will reach middle age or even old age before there is a good health care system.
The outcome, years later, as we enter the last two years of President Obama’s second term, is this: The Democrats can not nominate another black president, ever. The Republicans have succeeded in their strategy. Keeping the White in the White House.
And the Democrats let that happen.
Have you read the breakthrough novel of the year? When you are done with that, try:
or Paperback
*Please note:
Links to books and other items on this page and elsewhere on Greg Ladens' blog may send you to Amazon, where I am a registered affiliate. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, which helps to fund this site.
Your update is spot on Greg. I had hope for the US in 2008 but my cynicism has grown to pan galactic proportions in the past 6 years. You just know that if Hillary (or any Democratic female) gets elected, the same GOP/MSM collaboration roadmap will apply, and that by the time her administration is over it will be back to only white males need apply.
I wonder, what if another black Democratic party polly or maybe a black female Republican (Condi Rice?) could get up and become next POTUS .. Just to mess with their heads! 😉
(Yeah, unlikely but still, who knows! 2016 still a political eternity away and a lot can happen in that time.)
polly = politician -Aussie slang.
I don’t know.
Maybe it depends on what we mean by racist? We’re all raised in a cultural matrix / zeitgeist(?) / context which has a lot of racism in it. A lot of stereotypes float around and get repeated and become a sort of cultural background but then some people recognise this and try to fight back against it whilst still perhaps being influenced by it to varying degrees and at various times.
There’s a big difference between someone who spouts and believes in KKK type rhetoric and someone who slips up by repeating the odd racist cliche from time to time whilst not actually thinking races mean anything.
Perhaps there’s a spectrum we all (mostly?) fall on perhaps with extremes at each end from the KK to committed anti-racist activist who evaluate each word fro any overtones of racism at all?
There’s racist ideas and acts but I think most people if asked will say they opposed racism at least in principle and overt open racism is now socially really unacceptable hence the strong offended defensive reaction whenever anyone is called a racist. So is that progress? I think so even if some of us, many of us probably still have a lot way to go.
Pedantically Ill also note that many white folks without jobs and good income and /or not suburban but rural are also racist -indeed , from what I gather many of the most racist are also the poorest least financially secure rural folks due to lack of education, experience, increased fear of competition from out-groups etc ..
I am someone who always tries to judge individuals based only on their actions not their skin colour or other superficial physical traits. (Or gender, even religion etc ..) I don’t think “race” even really exists outside our cultural mythology – it is socially constructed not something actually real. Oh & I’m an Australian from European heritage and of caucasian “race” FWIW.
So am I racist?
I guess if one has to ask one is eh?
But I don’t know. I do know that I do try not to be and hopefully succeed in that. I think there are many others who feel the same way and try to do the same.