How much does politics affect teaching evolution? How is the “fairness” argument exploited to undermine evolution education? Genie Scott explores these and other antievolution strategies in a recent speech before the Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Where: Scottsdale, AZ. When: 4/17/2011
Have you read the breakthrough novel of the year? When you are done with that, try:
In Search of Sungudogoby Greg Laden, now in Kindle or Paperback
*Please note:
Links to books and other items on this page and elsewhere on Greg Ladens' blog may send you to Amazon, where I am a registered affiliate. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, which helps to fund this site.
Like this:
LikeLoading...
Spread the love
9 thoughts on “Creationism, Evolution, Education–and Politics”
Eugenie Scott’s name comes up in this 2009 interview with Kevin Anderson
I had to reprogram my receiver yesterday after our power came back. One of the radio stations that flashed on is a local fundie station. They were starting their “science lesson”. No crap, it was “How winter disproves evolution, the big bang, and proves the Earth is 3500 years old. ”
I did not listen. You can’t overestimate the crazy.
In her April 17/11 talk in Scottsdale, AZ, Eugenie Scott said:
***
“There is no evidence against evolution. There is no evidence against the idea that livings things shared common ancestry. All of the evidence that we have from biogeography, from comparative anatomy, from genetics, from the fossil record, from any number of different sources, that all is very compatible and pointing very clearly to the inference that living things had common ancestors. Nothing out there is running a big neon light saying, ‘Whoa! Evolution fails here! We have to toss it out!’
***
So what evidence would convince Eugenie (or any other evolutionist) that vertical evolution (information-building evolution) is false?
1. As the Nobel Prize winning biochemist J. B. S. Haldane responded to an overeager Popperian when asked what evidence would falsify evolution, he responded a fossil cat in the Pre-Cambrian strata. Needless to say, the said fossil cat has yet to be found.
2. Just before the Dover trial, scientists decoding the chimpanzee genome found the following. I’ll let Prof. Ken Miller describe what happened.
Creationism, Evolution, Education–and Politics all are interrupting each other in every factors.
If we want something pure and creative from our system so we need to differ politics from the education system and encourage the students the way they use their mind get engaged in creativity.
Eugenie Scott’s name comes up in this 2009 interview with Kevin Anderson
http://kgov.com/bel/20090911
http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100331/pdf/464664a.pdf
Evolution: The Creation Myth of Our Culture
http://www.trueorigin.org/evomyth01.asp
Too much!
An awful lot. In some places and classes.
I had to reprogram my receiver yesterday after our power came back. One of the radio stations that flashed on is a local fundie station. They were starting their “science lesson”. No crap, it was “How winter disproves evolution, the big bang, and proves the Earth is 3500 years old. ”
I did not listen. You can’t overestimate the crazy.
In her April 17/11 talk in Scottsdale, AZ, Eugenie Scott said:
***
“There is no evidence against evolution. There is no evidence against the idea that livings things shared common ancestry. All of the evidence that we have from biogeography, from comparative anatomy, from genetics, from the fossil record, from any number of different sources, that all is very compatible and pointing very clearly to the inference that living things had common ancestors. Nothing out there is running a big neon light saying, ‘Whoa! Evolution fails here! We have to toss it out!’
***
So what evidence would convince Eugenie (or any other evolutionist) that vertical evolution (information-building evolution) is false?
The article, Life is Complicated (1 April 2010, Nature) can now be accessed at:
http://www.lbl.gov/LBL-Programs/lifesciences/BissellLab/articles/2010-04-01_Nature%20News%20Feature%20Human%20Genome%20At%2010.pdf
The article, Life is Complicated (1 April 2010, Nature) can now be accessed at:
http://www.lbl.gov/LBL-Programs/lifesciences/BissellLab/articles/2010-04-01_Nature%20News%20Feature%20Human%20Genome%20At%2010.pdf
Re David @ #4
1. As the Nobel Prize winning biochemist J. B. S. Haldane responded to an overeager Popperian when asked what evidence would falsify evolution, he responded a fossil cat in the Pre-Cambrian strata. Needless to say, the said fossil cat has yet to be found.
2. Just before the Dover trial, scientists decoding the chimpanzee genome found the following. I’ll let Prof. Ken Miller describe what happened.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zi8FfMBYCkk
Creationism, Evolution, Education–and Politics all are interrupting each other in every factors.
If we want something pure and creative from our system so we need to differ politics from the education system and encourage the students the way they use their mind get engaged in creativity.
“How winter disproves evolution”
I MUST know more.